Lessons from Ebbw Vale

The deed is done. The letter is sent. Article 50 is triggered. And the EU has confirmed that we may still have a way back.

My reading of the runes is that attitudes towards and against Brexit have hardened, and there’s a good chunk of people who aren’t closely aligned with either but would quite like the rowing to stop.

Let me be clear. I think the decision to leave is an astoundingly poor one. The Leave campaign made a number of claims, almost all of which have now been dropped. Theresa May seems to have deliberately chosen a more extreme version of Brexit, although whether this is what will be delivered is not yet clear. The UK does not hold many cards, and the EU is now in the driving seat. We have handed over the conditions of nearly half of our trade wholesale to others. Companies are actively looking to relocate. Inflation is up, partly caused by the decline in the currency.

But not one of these facts is making any real difference to changing the views of most of the 52%. I wrote before the referendum about the need for hope – and how many in different parts of the UK felt hopeless. The blame was laid at the feet of the EU.

Earlier this week, BBC’s Newsnight broadcast a film by Nick Clegg of his visit to Ebbw Vale – an area which has benefitted from millions of EU investment, but still voted resoundingly to leave. His film uncovered that the investment has been into things – buildings, statues, roads and the like – rather than into people. In an area which was hit hard by the decline in mining in the 1980s, unemployment remains high. Having a new road is great, as long as you can afford to travel down it. Having a new statue of a dragon – well, possibly not so useful unless you’re employed as its cleaner.

This is the failure of the project. The jobs are still not there. People still feel hopeless. It’s not a question of how much money was invested, but what it was invested in. And, for that reason, a campaign to simply not leave the EU, or to take us back in, will fail to resonate in those areas, because all that will indicate is more of the same – more of our money paid into things rather than people.

In fairness, this isn’t wholly the failure of the EU. It’s compounded by decades of similar underinvestment by UK governments, of all colours. Big industry disappears, leaving little in its wake. Secure jobs become, at best, insecure. Communities become run ragged. The pride in contributing to something big is hard to maintain when you now drive a bus for the council.

So while I disagree with the decision to leave the EU, I can (I think) understand some of the emotions that drove some people to take that decision – and those would have been enough to swing it.

Investment needs to be better targeted. If you don’t think you’re going to get a good job, there is little incentive to get a good education. So it’s jobs that are needed, together with investment in schools and colleges to train up a workforce in the new skills that will be demanded.

The historic coal mines, steel mills and car production plants are probably long gone – but we should be investing in green, sustainable energy production. It’s still manufacturing, even if it’s slightly higher-tech. And there’s no reason why such facilities could not be manufactured in the Welsh valleys or the North East of England.

We need to change the narrative on the EU. Leaving removes our say in the EU’s future direction, and reduces our influence and purchasing power across the rest of the world. But by promoting an EU reform agenda which we can only pursue if we remain, and explaining how this benefits all those areas that voted Leave in June, we have a chance to start changing hearts. I fear it might be too late though.



  1. nigel hunter · · Reply

    The open university and university of the third age (which meets in pubs etc) could be encouraged to develop small business start up ideas that people have It could give people thoughts that they are not now put on the pile of riubbish, no longer needed. Stimulate them to new ideas. New small industries like the development of small wind generators or robots to enhance the disabled lives or even to train as nurses, we have a shortage. Give them hope. inspiration.

  2. nigel hunter · · Reply

    When investment money is available from wherever it comes it should be invested in small community industries’ like environmental.,Can community groups get together to aim for crowd funding to kick start new ideas that people in the community have. Leaders with vision (small scale or large scale) should be found to organize inspire the the people,maybe you? The Universities could be involved to help Shools could be opened up train the people ALONGSIDE the 6th form for example. If the peoples ideas are harnessed who knows where it can lead.

  3. nigel hunter · · Reply

    Spread my thoughts to the rest of Welsh Lib demsto see if anything can be done to achieve success

  4. Thanks Nigel. It ought to be noted that, while Ebbw Vale is referenced, this is not a Wales-specific piece – but rather how those who advocate Remain still reach out to change the narrative in various areas of the country, of which the Welsh valleys are one notable example.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

%d bloggers like this: